High-profile defense attorney Alan Jackson dodged becoming a “pariah in Hollywood” by dropping Nick Reiner as he faces accusations he killed his famous mom and dad Rob and Michele Reiner, insiders said Thursday.
Jackson abruptly quit the case Wednesday without an explanation beyond telling reporters he was legally and ethically barred from “explaining all the reasons” why — but whatever drove his decision, he won’t be ruffling the feathers of film and TV royalty during the pending trial of the murders of the Reiners.
Attorney Alan Jackson, right, addresses the court during an arraignment for Nick Reiner in LA on Jan. 7, 2026. via REUTERS
“The backlash is he becomes a pariah in Hollywood because Michele and Rob were beloved. There would be a real chance Hollywood business would dry up,” legal expert Royal Oakes told The Post.
Jackson could have been thinking more about his “reputation than money,” Oakes said — noting Hollywood A-listers have a small crew of influential attorneys they’d turn to if they run into legal trouble.
“You can count the number of those lawyers on one hand, Alan is on the list,” said Oakes, who isn’t involved in the Reiner case. “You know you’re a pariah in Hollywood when you fall off the short list, you’re on that list or you’re not. You’re going to know you’re off the list when the phone stops ringing.”
Nick Reiner’s trial could also see celebrities taking the stand, which means the accused killer’s attorney might have to ask tough questions. That could turn him into a bad guy in the eyes of the Hollywood elite, another attorney said.
“You are on the wrong side of this whole thing in terms of the facts and popularity,” the attorney, who wished to remain anonymous, told The Post.
One potential scenario would be comedian Conan O’Brien taking the stand due to the Reiners attending a Christmas party at the comedian’s house hours before the murders.
Rob Reiner with wife Michele and their offspring Romy, Nick and Jake in March 2015.michelereiner/Instagram
The California Post is coming soon. Sign up for updates.
Get in early. Be the first to know about launch and home delivery.
Enter your email address
By clicking above you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
During the party, guests wanted to call 911 on Nick Reiner as he was involved in a heated argument with his dad, but O’Brien allegedly told the celeb crowd, “It’s my house, my party, I’m not calling the police,” reports said.
“Just imagine Jackson’s cross-examination — ‘Nick needed help and had a chance to get it, we need the police, and no police, they resisted it,’” Oakes said.
“If Alan Jackson went ballistic, his name could be mud in Tinseltown,” he added.
And there’s the possibility that the victims may have had “shade” thrown their way as part of the defense, Oakes added — which would further drive Jackson out of the inner circle.
Rob Reiner and son Nick Reiner pictured together in August 2015.michelereiner/Instagram
Nick Reiner’s lawyer Alan Jackson stepped down just before his arraignment in Los Angeles on Wednesday.Mona Shafer Edwards / BACKGRID
There has been speculation the attorney bowed out due to his high price tag, or because of an undisclosed conflict of interest. But Jackson’s partner in the highly watched Karen Read case said saving his reputation would never have been his motivation for stepping aside.
“I’m sure this is a decision Alan didn’t take lightly,” said David Yannetti, who hasn’t spoken to his partner on the decision. “It’s always difficult, it’s our job to help others.”
He also pointed out the reasons that attorney’s usually drop cases including conflicts of interest, a breakdown in attorney and client relations, or for financial reasons. Jackson takes his job very seriously, he added.
“I had a front-row seat for three-and-a-half years,” Yannetti said. “He takes the ethics of this profession very seriously. We take these cases not because they’re hard, not easy.”